Network Computing is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Does EMC's DMX Measure Up?: Page 2 of 5

"This architecture is a big breakthrough for us," said Dave Donatelli, EMC's EVP of platform operations, at the launch in New York this week. "We've removed the major bottleneck -- the internal bandwidth of the system."

Competitors, though, dispute that the DMX really offers substantially better performance. "Their claims of performance is adding up the sum of the parts," said Phil Townsend, HDS's senior director of product marketing. They say the more relevant figure -- and the real architectural bottleneck -- is that the cache memory access on DMX is 16 GByte/s (32 cache segments multiplied by 500 MByte/s for each interface).

Fine, says EMC: The DMX still whomps the tar out of the nearest competitor. Its 16-GByte/s cache bandwidth is still well over the 10.6-GByte/s cache bandwidth Hitachi claims for the 9980V (four cache regions times 2.65 GByte/s provided by the Hi-Star crossbar switching architecture).

Table 1: High-End Storage Performance Specifications

Hitachi Lightning 9970V EMC Symmetrix DMX1000 Hitachi Lightning 9980V EMC Symmetrix DMX2000
Data Bandwidth 16 x 332 MB/s = 5.3 GB/s 64 x 500 MB/s = 32 GB/s 32 x 332 MB/s = 10.6 GB/s 128 x 500 MB/s = 64 GB/s
Message Bandwidth 16 x 166 MB/s = 2.6 GB/s 16 x 200 MB/s = 3.2 GB/s 32 x 166 MB/s = 5.3 GB/s 32 x 200 MB/s = 6.4 GB/s
Cache Regions 2 16 4 32
Cache Bandwidth 2 x 2.65 GB/s = 5.3 GB/s 16 x 500 MB/s = 8 GB/s 4 x 2.65 GB/s = 10.6 GB/s 32 x 500 MB/s = 16 GB/s
Cache Size 32 GB 64 GB 64 GB 128 GB
Front-End Connectivity 48 2-Gbit/s FC 48 2-Gbit/s FC 64 2-Gbit/s FC 96 2-Gbit/s FC
Processors 8 166MHz MIPS
8 200MHz MIPS
60 500MHz PowerPC 16 166MHz MIPS
16 200MHz MIPS
116 500MHz PowerPC
Source: EMC, HDS

Apart from this circular they-said/we-said quarrel, EMC's rivals bellyache that Hopkinton can't prove the DMX delivers superior performance, because EMC refuses to test its systems using industry-standard benchmarks.